The Dwarkesh Reference
2026-04-07

Michael Nielsen

How science actually progresses

Listen / read the full episode ↗

Predictions (4)

Where they disagreed

Dwarkesh
Michael Nielsen
Were Lorentz's ether interpretation and Einstein's relativity experimentally indistinguishable?
Yes, at the time the two were experimentally equivalent.
No, the 1940-41 muon experiments distinguish them: Lorentz had to keep patching his theory, while relativity predicted time dilation intrinsically from the start.
Is quantum computing's useful scope basically bounded (search, breaking encryption)?
It looks fairly narrow, mostly Grover-style search and Shor's algorithm.
Too early to say: we've thought about it for ~40 years without the physical devices, the equivalent of pre-PC classical computing; its domain could be very broad.

Mental models (5)

Claims (4)